
Two years after leaving Kansas, Reuben was in the field checking the growth of his corn when a well-dressed man drove up to his Iowa farm in a buggy. He looked official. Was he trouble? Reuben peered at the stranger from the cover of the field. The man got out of the rig and knocked. Would Margaret know how to deal with him, he wondered.
Margaret opened the door. After a brief discussion, she let him in. He was indeed a government official, a census taker. She offered him some fresh buttermilk and sat him down at the table.
“This won’t take long, Ma’am. I just need a few things about your family and farm. First off, what’s the name of the head of the household?”
Rrr..Reuben, Reuben De.. ,ah,… lay.”
How do you spell that, Ma’am?”
“D-I-L-L-A-Y”
“Got it. Sounds Irish.”
“Aye begorrah!” said Margaret, mimicking her grandfather’s old country accent.
“Reuben’s age?”
“Twenty-five.”
“Nativity?”
“Ohio”
“And you are his wife, obviously.”
“Yes. I’m Margaret. I’m 20, born in Indiana.
“Children?”
“Yes, two. Rosellen is two. Born in Kansas…, I mean Kentucky. Little Clinson is one. He was born here in Iowa.”
“Any others?”
Just the hired hand, George Wentworth.
”The value of your personal estate?”
“It’s assessed at $490.”
Margaret still didn’t understand how they had bought the place for cash two years ago. They had left Kansas almost penniless. Reuben wouldn’t say where he got the money. His work done, the man thanked her and left.
Reuben came into the house after the census taker was out of sight.
“That was the census taker. Why must we keep up this charade whenever a stranger comes by?”
Reuben looked at her with unblinking eyes.
“When will you tell me what you did in Kansas?”
Reuben didn’t answer.
“If you did do something there, wouldn’t Governor Medary’s amnesty proclamation cover you?”
“I don’t think so,” Reuben said glumly.
Margaret stared into his eyes, not understanding. Governor Samuel Medary had signed the amnesty bill five months after Reuben left Kansas. It ended the prosecutions of all the Jayhawkers, Bushwhackers, and Ruffians so long as they behaved. Then it hit her.
“Missouri? Did you do something in Missouri?” she asked, raising her voice.
Reuben blinked and glanced down at the floor.
“Damn you Reuben DeLay!”
Indeed, Reuben had left the Kansas border country in a hurry. The sheriff of Bates County, Missouri, was on his trail. It all began one September day in 1858 at the Barnes General store in Mound City. He ran into Abe Sandusky, one of his old Sugar Creek Company companions.
“Heard you were fixin’ to drag up.”
“Yep, the Missus already left for Iowa. She got tired of the Bushwhackers and Ruffians,” said Reuben. “I sold off nearly everything, ‘cept a little mare I’m kinda fond of.”
“That’s too bad,” Sandusky mused. “Ever think of gittin’ even?”
“Every damn minute of every damn day.”
“I hear old John Brown is planning a big raid into Missouri. Maybe we should tag along and git us some booty.”
“I dunno, anyone who rides with Brown after what happened at Pottawattamie would have to be a little daft. He’s got no compunction about killing. If they ever catch him, they’ll hang him along with anyone who’s with him.”
“Spose so, but I’d sure like to git back some of what them Ruffians stole. You up for a private raid?”
Reuben thought long and hard. He had just found a buyer for his claim and had sold off the crop and most of the stock. After paying off his debts, his purse now contained exactly forty-four dollars. That was two dollars more than he had when he arrived in Kansas in 1856. All that hard work for a dollar a year? he asked himself. Now he’d have to start all over. Besides, he had a wife and family to support.
Abe paused a second and pulled out a handbill that read:
Horse & Mule
Auction!
West Point
September 19
-H. Masters, Auctioneer.
Hmm, Reuben thought. Missouri had a reputation for good horse prices, and he had one to sell. Besides, Daisy, his little mare, had a special quality. Other horses followed her lead. He had noticed her leading them toward water and greener grass. She was a lead mare. That could be useful.
“Are you thinking what I’m thinking?” he said, pointing to the poster.
Sandusky looked at the handbill and broke out into a grin.
“How many do you figure we’d git?”
“Twenty or thirty, if we’re lucky.”
“If they’re good horses, that’s a lot of money. How many men would it take?”
“I’ve got a lead mare. If those Missouri horses will follow her, three riders ought to do it.”
“I could ask Ned Wolcott to come. He’s been burned out by them Bushwhackers twice.”
“Ned’s a good man. Let’s see if he wants in.”
A few days later, the men met again to formulate their plan. Reuben would go to West Point the day before the auction to consign the mare. Then he’d find a place nearby to spend the night. When all got quiet, he’d be joined by Ned and Abe as they released the horses. All that was left was to point them toward Kansas. If there were any guards at the auction site, Reuben would have to find a way to distract them.
The Friday before the auction, Reuben rode into West Point alone, leading the mare. Ned and Abe camped in a hidden coulee a few miles from town. The auction arena was on the far side of town. Reuben carefully checked out the route as he passed through. He saw two taverns on the main road. That spelled trouble. He imagined being spotted by a throng of drunken Missouri Ruffians as they tried to run the horses past the saloons. He’d have to find another route.
He located the auction site on the outskirts of town. It had a small auction barn with corrals in the back. He hitched the horses to a rail and went inside. Talk like you’re from Missourah, he cautioned himself.
“Kin I help ya?” said a man who appeared to be the auctioneer.
“Yep, I’m fixin’ to consign a fine mare for tomorrow’s auction.”
“Well, let me take a look at her.”
The two men went out to look at Daisy. The auctioneer, Herk Masters, sized her up, checking her ears, teeth, and hooves.
“She’ll do jes fine. Any papers?”
“No, Sir, but I can give ya a bill of sale.”
“That will work. If’n she’s stole, me and the rightful owner will be a-huntin’ ya’ll down. C’mon back inside and fill out the paperwork.”
Reuben used his old Sugar Creek Company pseudonym, Isaac Smythe, on the documents. He gave an address near Nevada, Missouri.
“You stayin’ overnight?” asked the auctioneer as they put Daisy in a pen.
“I reckon so,” drawled Reuben. “Might just lay my blanket under yon tree.”
“Maybe ya’ll could help my man Jeb keep an eye on the corral tonight. I’d hate to see some damn Jayhawker try to steal what ain’t his’n.”
“Glad to help out.”
“Good. I’ll pay you three dollars if’n you stand guard tonight and help with the stock tomorrow.”
“Now that sounds mighty fine. I need to run back to town and git some victuals fust, but I’ll be right back.”
The two men shook hands, and Reuben rode back toward town. This time, he found an alternate route along a creek to avoid the main part of the town. He met Ned and Abe at their camp and filled them in on the setup. They listened attentively.
“I need you two there at 2 AM. Just before you get to town, take a right and follow the road along the creek so you don’t attract attention. We’ll trail the horses back that way when we come through. Hide yourselves in the stand of trees next to the entrance. I’ll signal you by waving a lit torch. No talking. There’ll be another man standing guard with me. I’ll try to make sure he ain’t awake.”
“Sounds good. I can’t wait to even up the score for all the mischief them Ruffians done,” said Ned.
His two accomplices bid Reuben goodbye and slipped back into hiding. On his way back through town, Reuben stopped at a tavern. He ate and bought a jug of fine Kentucky Bourbon. He hoped Jeb would like it.
Back at the auction house, Reuben and Jeb settled in for the night. They agreed to take two-hour shifts. Reuben twisted the cork on the jug and offered it to Ned.
“Ain’t nuthin’ finer than good ole bourbon from Kentuck,” he remarked.
Jeb took a sip, savoring the flavor.
“Well, swizzle my twizzle. Damn fine, my friend, damn fine.”
“Drink up. My Missus don’t like me a-drinkin’. It needs to be gone before I head for home.”
“I’m your huckleberry,” grinned Jeb as he took a long pull on the jug.
It’s going to be a good night, Reuben thought.
Reuben let an already mellow Jeb have the jug as the man ended his Midnight shift. Jeb was happily sipping on it each time Reuben came by on his rounds of the corral. Within an hour, Jeb’s snoring proved the alcohol had worked.
At 2 AM, Reuben bundled up a sheaf of straw and lit it to signal his comrades. The plan was working. The men quietly snuck into the pens and shooed the horses through the open gates. Reuben put a halter on Daisy and led her to the front of the herd. He’d ride point with Daisy in tow. Ned and Abe would take up the rear flanks.
In half an hour, they were beyond the sleeping town of West Point. Reaching the main road, they picked up the pace and raced for Kansas. They had nearly 40 fine Missouri horses in tow. The Bates County posse would not find their trail until late the next morning. By then, the Jayhawkers were out of their jurisdiction. Frustrated, the sheriff sent a posse member to Linn County to see if he could identify the inside man whom auctioneer Masters described. A young man named DeLay, who had just left the area, fit the description.
The horses were sold, and Reuben left Kansas a wiser and richer man. The border troubles and the issue of slavery were now behind him.
Or so he thought.
Index- Unbowed: The saga of a Civil War Cavalryman- https://azrockdodger.com/2025/02/06/unbowed-the-saga-of-a-civil-war-cavalryman-index/







